Dairy Business Association
August 1, 2016
The Dairy Business Association (DBA), which was created in 1999 and is based in Green Bay, is run by agri-business and large dairy interests that support looser agriculture and environmental regulations and enforcement. The group is backed by dozens of wealthy special interest sponsors that have contributed more than $2.1 million to statewide and legislative candidates, including more than $710,000 to Republican Gov. Scott Walker in recent years.
Those sponsors (Table) include big-name law firms, banking, energy, and large agri-business interests, like Foley and Lardner, Alliant Energy, American Foods Group, BMO Harris Bank, Cargill, Merck, and Monsanto.
The DBA’s backers give it considerable political clout that helps it move a lobbying agenda, which includes legislative bills and state rules to loosen land use, high-capacity well, wetland, groundwater protection, and factory farm regulations and enforcement. Factory farms are formally called concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs) and house several hundred or thousands of cows, hogs, chickens and turkeys.
In a February 2016 opinion piece about controversial legislation to ease state oversight of high-capacity wells, which did not pass, DBA lobbyist John Holevoet wrote: “Our ready access to fresh water gives Wisconsin a competitive advantage in attracting new farms and other businesses that rely on water. We should be promoting this advantage, not regulating it out of existence.”
The DBA, which spent $179,045 on lobbying in 2015, employs five lobbyists, including Bill McCoshen, a prominent State Capitol lobbyist who was chief of staff to former longtime GOP Gov. Tommy Thompson. In the last full 2013-14 legislative session, the DBA spent nearly $304,000 on lobbying state policymakers.
In addition to lobbying on proposed state policy and spending, media reports as far back as 2010 show the DBA has met directly with the Department of Natural Resources (DNR) and the Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection (DATCP) to change the way the agencies site, permit and regulate factory farms. Such ready access by a large corporate interest has raised questions about the DNR’s independence from both inside and outside the agency. “This particular lobbying group has been able to elbow its way into the higher levels of the regulatory agency. That kind of access is unprecedented,” Jamie Saul, a former Midwest Environmental Advocates attorney, said in a March 2010 media report.
The families of seven of the DBA’s 10-member board of directors own factory farms, including the group’s president, Gordon Speirs, owner of Shiloh Dairy in Brillion. Early last month, heavy rains washed thousands of gallons of manure from Shiloh Dairy into Plum Creek. The creek runs into the Fox River in northern Calumet County. The DNR said Shiloh Dairy may face enforcement action from the manure runoff. Both Calumet and Kewaunee counties have a large number of factory farms. Nearly a third of wells tested in Kewaunee County last year were so contaminated that the water isn’t safe to drink.
The DBA’s lobbying activities are just one part of its political arsenal. The group operates a conduit, which delivered $63,340 in large individual contributions to legislative and statewide candidates between January 2005 and December 2015. Some of the campaign cash came from the group’s sponsors as well as other factory farm owners, and agri-business and construction interests. Conduits are legal check-bundling operations often run by lobbyists and special interest groups that collect contributions from individuals, bundle them together and deliver one large check to a candidate.
The DBA’s conduit contributions supported Democratic and GOP legislative and statewide candidates, but substantially more went to Republicans – about $48,300 versus about $15,000. The top recipients of DBA conduit contributions were Republican Gov. Scott Walker, $8,740; former Democratic Gov. Jim Doyle, $3,450; and former GOP state representative and lieutenant governor candidate Brett Davis, $3,300.
The top individual contributors through the DBA conduit were Dean Doornink, of Baldwin, owner of Jon-De-Farm, $4,000; John Vrieze, of the Town of Emerald, owner of Emerald Dairy, $3,800; and Mark Mashlan, of Kaukauna, an executive with Fox Structures, $2,875.
The group’s annual conventions have drawn heavy hitters from both parties. Walker and GOP Assembly Speaker Robin Vos addressed the DBA’s most recent 2016 annual convention, and Doyle spoke at its 2008 state meeting.
In addition to the individual contributions through the group’s conduit, the DBA also contributed $35,900 in three contributions in 2014 to the Republican Governors Association’s (RGA) 527 group. The RGA spends several millions of dollars each year to support GOP candidates for governor across the country. In 2014, the RGA’s state political action committee spent nearly $4 million on mostly negative broadcast ads to support Walker’s successful reelection. 527 groups are tax-exempt political nonprofit groups that are named after the U.S. Internal Revenue Service code that governs them. These organizations, which are run by powerful business and other special interests, can accept and spend unlimited amounts of unregulated contributions on electioneering activities.
Individual and Political Action Committee Contributions
by Staff and Sponsors of the Dairy Business Association
to GOP Gov. Scott Walker and All Legislative and Statewide Candidates
January 2010 – December 2015
|DBA Sponsor or Staff||Gov. Scott Walker||All Candidates|
|Foley & Lardner||$141,043||$452,044|
|Michael, Best & Friedrich||$85,745||$334,605|
|Wisconsin Public Service||$110,406||$259,573|
|Whyte, Hirschboeck & Dudek||$58,931||$198,277|
|Klondike Cheese Factory||$65,500||$123,850|
|American Foods Group||$29,700||$65,950|
|BMO Harris Bank||$23,091||$57,063|
|Schenck & Associates||$17,210||$37,140|
|Orion Energy Systems||$6,750||$21,365|
|Rural Mutual Insurance||$1,278||$14,008|
|Gordon Speirs, DBA president, and Catherine, Shiloh Dairy||$12,250||$13,500|
|Jerry Meissner (DBA Board) and Diane, Norm-E-Lane||$9,250||$10,725|
|Cargill and Cargill Animal Nutrition||$6,929||$8,429|
|Investors Community Bank||$1,096||$7,735|
|Quality Liquid Feeds||$5,000||$7,250|
|Mike North (DBA Board) and Jennifer, Commodity Risk Management Group||$1,000||$3,950|
|AgStar Financial Services||$1,500||$3,925|
|Ansay & Associates||$1,910||$3,860|
|VITA Plus Corp.||$3,400||$3,750|
|Landmark Services Cooperative||$2,476||$3,676|
|Dairy Business Association||$700||$2,550|
|Michael Gerrits (DBA Board) Country Aire Farms||$2,500||$2,500|
|Komro Sales & Services||$1,550||$2,050|
|DuPont (a DuPont subsidiary is a DBA sponsor)||$1,175||$1,925|
|Hampel Corp. (a Hampel subsidiary is a DBA sponsor)||$150||$1,200|
|Cornette Farm Supply||$1,050||$1,150|
|Boehringer Ingelheim Pharmaceuticals||$0||$1,090|
|Roach & Associates||$950||$950|
|J. Jaden Inc.||$0||$850|
|Nutrition Service Co.||$550||$550|
|Family Insurance Center||$500||$500|
|Hastings Mutual Insurance||$0||$500|
|GEA Farm Technologies||$0||$300|
|GPS Dairy Consulting||$300||$300|
|Lloyd (DBA Board) & Daphne Holterman Rosy Lane Holsteins||$0||$250|
|Wisconsin Cheese Makers Association||$0||$200|
|Darlington Dairy Supply||$0||$200|
|Professional Dairy Services||$100||$200|
|Twohig, Rietbrock, et al||$0||$150|
|GreenStone Farm Credit Services||$150||$150|
|Elanco Animal Health||$100||$100|