Analysis reveals some students gave to same candidates at same time as parents
October 22, 2007
Madison - Contributors identified as “student” in campaign finance reports gave $86,243 to candidates for statewide office and the legislature from 2002 through June 2007, a Wisconsin Democracy Campaign analysis shows.
The typical money struggles people associate with college students certainly did not appear to be a problem for many of these 177 student contributors, whose 303 contributions ranged from $7.50 to $5,000.
Thirty-one students contributed $1,000 or more, another 18 contributed between $500 and $988, an additional 67 contributed $200 to $490 each, 51 contributed between $100 and $175 and 10 contributed under $100 (Table).
WDC also found some student contributors who made some of the largest contributions did so around the same time and to the same candidates as their parents. Twelve of the 31 students who contributed $1,000 or more made their contributions at the time or shortly after one or both of their parents had given the same candidate the maximum allowable contribution in that election cycle.
State rules require campaign contributors to be at least 14 years old but contributors are not required to say how old they are. State law prohibits making contributions in the name of another person or reimbursing someone for making campaign contributions. That law is designed to prevent individuals from exceeding the limit on contributions a candidate may collect from one person.
Topping the list of student contributors was Vikram Saini, of Elm Grove, who gave Democratic Governor Jim Doyle $5,000 on March 8, 2002. His father, Dr. Bhupinder Saini of Advanced Pain Management, also contributed $5,000 to Doyle the same day.
Two contributors listed as students – Matthew Troha of Kenosha and David Sensenbrenner of Madison – each made multiple contributions totaling $4,000 from 2002 through June 30, 2007.
Troha contributed $2,000 to Doyle and $500 to Democratic legislative candidate Roger Dier in 2002. He also made two contributions totaling $1,500 to the Assembly Democratic Campaign Committee in 2003. Troha’s contribution to Doyle coincided with $16,000 in contributions by four other Troha family members August 22, 2002. His contributions to the Assembly Democratic Campaign Committee – $1,000 on July 16 and $500 on March 21 of 2003 – coincided with $5,000 in contributions made by five other family members on July 16 and July 17, 2003 and $1,500 in contributions by three family members between March 21 and March 28, 2003.
Matthew’s father, Dennis Troha, was charged early this year with two felonies accusing him of funneling more than $100,000 to family members so they could make campaign contributions to state and federal candidates and party committees to win approval of a proposed $800 million casino in Kenosha. No other family members have been charged in the federal investigation. Dennis Troha, who severed his ties with the casino project shortly before the charges were filed, has agreed to plead guilty to two lesser misdemeanor charges of exceeding campaign contributions limits.
David Sensenbrenner, the son of former Madison Mayor Joe Sensenbrenner and his wife, Mary Ellyn, made three contributions totaling $3,000 in 2002 to then Democratic gubernatorial candidate Kathleen Falk. He also made $500 contributions to Doyle and to Democratic legislative candidate Corey Ladick. David Sensenbrenner’s 2002 contributions to Falk included $1,500 on August 19, $500 on August 28 and $1,000 on February 28 which closely coincides with his mother’s contributions to Falk – $500 on August 30 and $1,000 on February 14.
Five student contributors gave a total of $2,500 each. John Walsh, son of Madison attorney and longtime Doyle supporter David Walsh, gave Doyle $2,000 in 2002 and another $500 in 2006. Courtney Oldenburg, daughter of Milwaukee businessman Wayne Oldenburg, contributed $2,500 to Republican gubernatorial candidate Mark Green on July 24, 2006, the same day her father gave Green $5,500.
Emily Sussman, a student in New York, contributed $2,500 to Doyle on October 12, 2006 and Tim Van de Kamp, a Madison student, contributed $2,500 to Democratic gubernatorial candidate Tom Barrett on May 21, 2002. Molly Walsh, of Boulder, Colorado, gave Doyle two contributions in 2002 and 2004 totaling $2,500. WDC could not determine if she is related to the other Walshes.
Michael Walsh, a Madison student and another son of David Walsh, contributed $2,000 to Doyle on August 30, 2002, the same day his brother, John, gave Doyle $2,000. WDC could not determine if the Michael Walsh from Madison and a Michael Walsh identified as a student living in Westminster, Colorado when he gave Doyle two $500 contributions in 2006 were the same person.
Ninety-one candidates for statewide office and the legislature and three legislative leadership committees accepted student contributions from 2002 through June 30, 2007. Topping the list was Doyle, who accepted $26,185, or 30 percent of the total student contributions to all candidates during the period.
Doyle was followed by Gary Baier, a Republican Senate candidate in 2004 who accepted $6,000 – six $1,000 contributions – from six students in two different families all on August 6, 2004. Their parents also gave $1,000 each to Baier on the same day. The maximum amount a Senate candidate may take from an individual is $1,000 per election cycle.
Kathleen Falk, a 2002 Democratic gubernatorial candidate and 2006 attorney general candidate, accepted $5,073 from student contributors followed by Green who got $3,950 and Democratic legislator Gordon Hintz who accepted $3,393.
|Saini, Vikram||Elm Grove||$5,000|
|Sussman, Emily||New York, NY||$2,500|
|Van de Kamp, Tim||Madison||$2,500|
|Walsh, Molly||Boulder, CO||$2,500|
|Fienen, Michael||San Francisco, CA||$1,435|
|Hebl, Matt||Sun Prairie||$1,425|
|Hebl, Andrew||Sun Prairie||$1,125|
|Hebl, Jenny||Sun Prairie||$1,025|
|Baer, Eric||Manitowish Waters||$1,000|
|Baer, Mora||Manitowish Waters||$1,000|
|Baer, Vanessa||Manitowish Waters||$1,000|
|Mandarini, Louis||Coral Gables, FL||$1,000|
|Walsh, Michael||Westminster, CO||$1,000|
|Wolfberg, Elias||Cambridge, MA||$988|
|Bacon, Laura L||Watertown||$500|
|Curry, William H||New Holstein||$500|
|Ennis, Natalie||Wisconsin Dells||$500|
|George, Dawn||Fort Atkinson||$500|
|Kidwell, Kristen||Holland, MI||$500|
|Mehring, Paul||Austin, TX||$500|
|Rossman, Amy T||Los Angeles, CA||$500|
|Sweasy, Janette||Bay City||$500|